|
200Spring2017
Page history
last edited
by Chris Werry 7 years, 3 months ago
Sample Syllabi, Assignment Sequence, Schedule & Course Reader
Main Texts Used in Assignments
Overviews and Descriptions of Teaching Activities
First Weeks: Introducing the Course & Applying Concepts to Short texts
Unit 1: Analyzing & Evaluating Hari
- Johann Hari's "The Likely Cause of Addiction Has Been Discovered, and It Is Not What You Think"
- Video of Hari's TED talk that presents an argument very close to the written text. There is a transcript, and you could also have students examine the comments section.
- The site for his book Chasing the Scream has many useful resources, videos, interviews and links. Students could research a section of the site in order to investigate the rhetorical situation and begin evaluating Hari's argument.
- Background on Hari: see the bio on his publisher's page, his twitter feed, Wikipedia page, and facebook page.
- The web site for Hari's book has a quiz that students can take. The quiz explores what people know and assume about addiction and the war on drugs.
- Animated version of Hari's argument. Comic book exploration of the rat park experiment by Stuart McMillen.
- "4 Things Johann Hari Gets Wrong about Addition- Updated with a Response from Hari" The Fix
- "Chasing the Scream"- New York Times Review of Books
- "Stop Telling Me 'Everything You Think You Know about Addiction is Wrong'" Addiction and Mental Health Blog
- "Johann Hari: 'The Opposite of Addicition Isn't Sobriety- It's Connection'"- The Guardian
- Response to Huff Post Article: The Likely Cause of Addiction has Been Discovered, and It’s Not what You Think – Dr. Simon Says Science
- "The Portuguese Puzzle: Decriminalization of Drugs and Drug Usage" David Henderson, Library of Economics and Liberty
- Naomi Klein interview with Hari that largely supports and extends his argument. The title is, "Does Capitalism Drive Drug Addiction?"
Teaching Materials for Hari
- Teaching notes for Hari
- Collected teaching materials for unit 1 (parts of this document refer not to Hari but to a different text, however most of the teaching material can be adapted for use with Hari)
Sample homework for a past section of 200 and 100 (both sets of homework can be adapted for use with Hari).
- Group work/presentation on responses/challenges to Hari. Each group is assigned to summarize and synthesize a set of responses to Hari’s argument in order to examine the conversation the text participates in, and also to look for critical questions, objections, counterexamples, absences, etc.
- Hypothesis commenting group for annotating Hari. Cam has created a group. We could annotate together.
- Evaluation exercise: play Elbow's "doubting and believing" game, where you interpret Hari's article generously vs. playing devil's advocate. Groups could be assigned to do this using a short text that A) extends, clarifies and supports Hari, as for example this interview with Hari, Gabor (an expert Hari draws) and Amy Goodman. Or, you could play devil's advocate drawing on this challenge to Hari. In both cases, students could evaluate the quality of the support or critique.
Evaluating Hari
Evaluation exercise: play Elbow's "doubting and believing" game, where you interpret Hari's article generously vs. playing devil's advocate. Groups can do this using a short text that A) extends, clarifies and supports Hari, as for example this interview with Hari, Gabor (an expert Hari draws) and Amy Goodman. Or, we could play devil's advocate drawing on this challenge to Hari. In both cases, we will evaluate the quality of the support or critique.
There is some useful material in the reader on evaluation on page 37-47. As a rule of thumb, you may want to consider the following areas:
- Reasoning - how are claims organized and constructed? (chains of reasoning; GASCAP)
- Support - how are claims supported?
- Source selection, representation and fact-checking
- How are strategies used? (For example, how effectively and fairly are opposing views represented? How well are appeals - ethos, pathos, logos - established given the rhetorical situation?)
- Frames - how are definitions, categories, narratives and metaphors used to establish a frame
- Assumptions and implications
- Vulnerability to counterexamples, counterarguments and objections
- What is left out of the argument?
These criteria (and others) should always be analyzed in relation to the author's audience, context and purpose.
Unit 2: The Rhetoric of Demagoguery (Lens Assignment)
Demagoguery - some possible examples from social media
Unit 3: "Fake" News & Critical Digital Literacy
End of Semester Resources & the WPA
200Spring2017
|
Tip: To turn text into a link, highlight the text, then click on a page or file from the list above.
|
|
|
|
|
Comments (0)
You don't have permission to comment on this page.